Hack

Hack: Leading the “uncontrollable”.........a practical approach.

by Gerhard Verwey - MBA student, Massey University

July 17, 2011 at 11:09pm

9 Ratings:

  • Overall 4.665
  • Innovative 4.89
  • Detail 4.44

Contribution Summary

Summary

The idea of driving the personal growth of independent sales contractors to achieve more sales, especially when you will be using their targets to be communicated from the bottom up in determining actual company objectives, will certainly ruffle the feathers of the traditionalists. 

Fear of losing control can be a dampening factor to realise value adding to all role players, but radical reform and transformation of this current environment, from being production focussed to a people development strategy will ensure long term sustainability of new business flow.
Problem

To achieve company goals, sales intermediaries are often at the receiving end of the pressure hose. Targets are handed down, quite lavishly from top to down. More than often this process are accompanied by all the motivational “jargon” (and a hidden threat), backed by academic theories to proof that “we are on the right track” and are “supporting you all the way”. The consequences for not living up to the required company standards can be quite devastating, not only to the perceived non-performer, but also in opportunities lost to the company in the long term.

Short term profits come before relationships. Not protecting and building on human capital, can be short sighted and costly, especially when recruitment drives need to be put in place to replace the so called under- performers

Solution

The vision is to create an alternative methodology of increasing production by developing, extracting human potential and raising people to new discoveries of themselves, instead of driving rigid sales targets. After all, they are the life blood of your corporate existence.

A common structure used to attract new business i.e. as employed in the life assurance industry (but not restricted to this industry) is to utilise a Business Development Manager (BDM) to service contracted sales advisers. These are independent individuals (not fixed employees) whose contractual existence is depending on meeting their contractual targets as set by the company. Why then do we forget that this is a symbiotic relationship? 

A negotiated approach, on all levels, to bring about change is envisaged: 

  1. Get management consent to change the status quo. Making management feeling good about them and subordinates (applying cognitive dissonance). 
  2. Brainstorming with the adviser and get acceptance and commitment to future involvement. Three lists should come from this: 

      - Ideas for immediate usefulness
      - Areas for further exploration
      - New approaches to the problem
Some creative effort is required to extract useful ideas. 

3.     Develop and equip the BDM with the necessary skills and tools to assist and  motivate the adviser towards self- 
        fulfilment, happiness and achievements of  targets. It is important to note that this should be done within
        allowable practices and does not make the BDM a “mini-psychiatrist”.

 4.     Head office has a strategic function to support, train, communicate and develop feedback systems. The focus 
         should not just be on the figures, but also addressing the motivational aspects of self development. Reporting
         becomes a process of sharing and building on information flows.

       Having the statistics and profile development on record will also assist with  succession planning should a BDM
       be replaced.

5.    Create the “funnel” to do targeting upwards. The different levels of self development will determine a whole new
        outlook on the figures, and senior management must be prepared to deal with this upside-down manner of
        compiling goals into one company target.

Practical Impact

The impact on the different role players are as follows: 

The sales adviser 

The adviser will have a better understanding of himself and his self awareness, especially in relations with other people. An increase in awareness of perceptual limitations and insight in why others respond to him they way they do can enhance their ability to sell. 

Sales advisers who is motivated, having clear role perceptions and sufficient resources (situational factors), backed by the related skills and knowledge (ability) will certainly be a winner to back for the future. If they can align (with the backing of the BDM) their behaviour to goals, behaviour modification will impact positively on discipline and self-esteem; boding well for future profitability to all parties involved. 

Communication and coordinating processes between BDM and adviser can be done via informal methods i.e. face to face or more advanced information technology systems. In an open relationship the BDM becomes part of the hardcore business aspects of the adviser, including personal time management. Another radical idea to consider in this regard is to first allocate time for personal activities, the time left will be used for production. It might just be a revelation on how much time there is available to work!

 The BDM 

The role of the BDM is moving away from one of merely applying targets as communicated from top down, “collecting business” and a simple kindling of a friendly environment.

 This can be the power of the self-fulfilling prophecy in action. By conducting regular and specific feedback sessions on the progress of development vs. targets achieved, relationships are preserved and individual differences resolved by applying proper conflict resolution. Engaging in the most appropriate goal setting methods can be both challenging and rewarding, but is ensuring long term relationships and an understanding of each other; surely securing a annuity stream of future business.

Head Office/Senior Management

 By changing the top to bottom model, management can be in touch with reality in terms of what they want to achieve. By switching from their own “stretch goals” and blue sky thinking to a practical, real time approach will prevent “nasty surprises”. Main sources of income are secured with a fair indication of expected future income; making strategic planning easier. The question can be asked who is controlling who.....

Challenges

Concerns that come to mind are:

1)      Cost of designing systems that are able to link personal development models, time management, goal setting and feedback methods.

2)      Getting commitment from senior management.

3)      Linking company strategies and management accounting objectives to the model as proposed in 1).

4)      Acceptance by BDM’s to a revamp of their roles.

5)      Getting consent from the customer (adviser).

First Steps

1. A visionary organisation can move forward as a sustainable entity, when they are prepared to start thinking outside
    the box and show the willingness to rely on their main source of income – human capital – to meet company 
    objectives.

2. Focussing on people development requires a high level of trust, strong willpower, acceptance, focus and
    commitment by all parties involved; especially when company goals are determined from the bottom up and not by
    forcing targets onto intermediaries.

3. Dependency on a top down approach is reduced. The gearing effect of this voluntary approach seek to be more
    rewarding than the old boring way of telling people what is required; let them tell you what can be done in terms of
   their capabilities and help them to build on that
. Formal planning, managing and reporting are now supplemented
   with a strong focus on self awareness and personal development.  

Credits
Dr B. Frey, Massey University
- Thank you for opening the mind
Helpful Materials

De Bono, E. (1980). Lateral Thinking – A Textbook of Creativity (pp.134-138, 232).  Middlesex: Penguin Books.

Fisher, K. (1993). Leading Self-Directed Work Teams. New York: McGraw-Hill, Inc.

Maltz, M. (1985). Psycho-Cybernetics and self-fulfilment (p20). New York: Bantam Books.

McShane S., Olekalns, M. & Travaglione, T. (2010). Organisational behaviour on the Pacific Rim. North Ryde NSW: McGraw-Hill.

Moreau, E. (2010). Dare to dream again. Onehunga: Leaving Almost Ltd.

Semler, R.; (1993). Maverick. (p4). London: Mackays of Chatham plc

Images:
  • No images at this time
Videos:
  • No videos at this time

Input

You need to register in order to submit a comment.

Join the MIX Now

You need to register in order to rate this contribution.

Join the MIX Now

Comments

Hans Fryer

No, it is not a sensitive topic. It is normally only sensitive when it concerns head-office.  More 'managers' in head office must climb down from their little ivory towers and start learning basics. The normal thing they do is run with their own selfish idea, and if it does'nt work, either blame others or resign and repeat the process at another company. This is definitely worth taking further !!!!

Sean Watson

A sensitive topic indeed, but certainly one that is justifiable and requires further investigation. I can see that this approach can add value to a range of sectors (certainly in the IT business). This model can certainly be developed and applied. A fresh approach indeed.
(Sean Watson, IT consultant, UK)